Review form
- Please return the completed form in text format to the Editor.
- If needed, use latex notation for mathematical symbols.

Author(s):

Overall evaluation category (A-E):
(A: Excellent; B: Good; C: Average; D: Poor; E: Null)

Presentation and clarity (A-E):
Originality (A-E):
Significance of theory (A-E):
Significance of application (A-E):
Appropriate title, abstract and keywords (A-E):
Appropriate figures and tables (A-E):
Bibliography (A-E):
English language (A-E):

Final recommendation (select one of):
- Acceptable for publication, as it is, or with minor changes
- Acceptable for publication with major changes
- Not acceptable for publication, but could be resubmitted
- Not acceptable for publication, and should not be resubmitted

Detailed comments:

Confidential comments to the editor (not communicated to authors):