Ryszard W. Kluszczynski
Four Chapters from the History of the Polish Avant-garde Film
The history of the avant-garde cinema in Poland began in 1930. Since
then numerous interesting films have been made, many filmmakers have developed
their uniques film styles and poetics. Among them there are few phenomena
of extreme importance. The films of Franciszka and Stefan Themersons, animation
of Jan Lenica, Walerian Borowczyk, and of other artists from the late fifties
and early sixties, films made by the members of "Film Form Workshop", and
works by Zbigniew Rybczynski, formed together the main and the most influential
stream in the avant-garde filmmaking in Poland. They all composed also
a line of continuation, since the artists of "Film Form Workshop" and Rybczynski,
extended the Themersons' interests, ideas, and experiments. In the mid-eighties
the history of the experimental cinema in Poland seemed to be over. The
unfavourable conditions, the lack of facilities, and the increasing access
to video equipment, wer the major reasons to transform the Polish film
avant-garde into the video avant-garde. The coming time will show whether
this end was ultimate or temporary.
Films by Franciszka and Stefan Themersons constitute the most interesting
part of the history of independent, experimental, pre-war cinema in Poland.
Between 1930 when they made film Apteka (Pharmacy), and 1945 when they
completed The Eye and the Ear, the Themersons created seven films (the
last two when already residing in Great Britain). Their significance for
the development of the avant-garde film in Poland is enormous. The Themersons
were the founders of many organisations and events held to promote the
film avant-garde in Poland (as, e.g., the "Film Authors Co-op.", film magazine
"f.a", screenings of experimental films from England, France, etc.). They
are regarded as the precursors of structuralist film, the pioneers of expanded
cinema, initiators of main tendencies in Polish experimental filmmaking.
The Themersons' film strategy was characterised by the exceptional concern
with the substance of image. Their inventiveness was not confined to formal
experiments only, which brought new dimensions to the iconic sphere of
the cinema and were frequently inspired by photography, but they were also
interested in more fundamental issues such as the ontology of the film
image, and the nature of creative processes in filmmaking. These interests
are evident both in the films and in the writings of Stefan Themerson,
among which the essay The Urge to Create Visions is of particular importance.
In the essay the cinema is discussed in the context of the history of man's
visual experience, with its origins discovered in a Bushman tale, when
"a girl from long ago took a handful of embers and threw them up into the
air; and the sparks became stars". Themerson's persistent "praise of slovenliness"
can be regarded not only as the apologia of chance, outlining the aleatory
method in filmmaking, but also as a sketch in the history of visual arts,
for which the film has always been a hidden archetypal model. The Themersons'
idea of the "urge to create visions", as the only valid stimulus for filmmaking,
accounted for the unique character of their oeuvre in which a diversity
of poetic devices used in particular films is compatible with consistently
uniform artistic expression. This trait of the Themersons' films - a combination
of pure "filminess" with intermedialism (relationship to other arts) -
was later to become one of the main characteristics of the Polish avant-garde
The first post-war decade in Poland, for political reasons, was a most
discouraging period for any autonomous artistic practice, including independent
cinema, which lost its significance at that time. The end of the fifties
only brought a revival of experimental film. The shift of interests towards
broadly understood animated film was essential for that period. The films
of Walerian Borowczyk and Jan Lenica - Byl sobie raz (Once Upon a
Time, 1957), Szkola (School, 1957), Dom (House, 1958) - were recognised
as initiating the experimental trend in Polish animation. Collage structure,
pixilation, combination of live action and animation were the most dinstictive
features of their style. A separate position in this context was occupied
by two films of Mieczyslaw Waskowski: Somnambulicy (Somnambulists) and
Uwaga, malarstwo (Attention, Painting), both realised in 1957. The pictures,
made on the glass plate with paint applied to its surface, were a unique
attempt at achieving tachiste/action painting effects in film. Another
significant contribution was made by Andrzej Pawlowski. His Kineformy (Cineforms)
consisted in the projecting of a moving, spatial and abstract models onto
a screen, through a special image-distorting lens. Pawlowski was using
two crank-like handles to move the models and the lenses. The light, passing
through the lenses, distorted the forms, resulting in a very complex images.
In 1957 Pawlowski made a film version of his light show, also entitled
Kineformy. The next steps in film experiment in Poland were made by the artists of "Film
Workshop began in 1970 from the initiative of a group of students and
graduates of Lodz Film, TV and Theatre School. Together with the filmmakers
there are in the Workshop painters, musicians, cameramen, poets, technicians...
Workshop realises films, recordings and TV transmissions, sound programmes,
art exhibitions, different kind of events and interventions... Workshop
also follows the theoretical and critical activity. Workshop does not represent
any commercial activity and their makers work totally gratuitously. (The
Manifesto of the Film Form Workshop, 1970) "The Film Form Workshop" was
founded by Jozef Robakowski, Ryszard Wasko, Wojciech Bruszewski, Pawel
Kwiek. In their effort to examine and develop the means of expression of
audio-visual arts, the members of the FFW emphasised the need for systematic
research on the medial properties of film. The preoccupation with medialism
situated the activity of the FFW in the context of the broadly understood
conceptual trend in art, manifested in the cinema in the rise of so-called
structural film. Drawing upon the traditions of Polish, and Russian avant-garde
of the 1920s and 1930s, the participants of the Workshop developed their
own way within the conceptual movement, with their artistic and theoretical
approach being particularly indebted to the ideology and practice of constructivism.
The first period of the activities of the FFW was marked by the attempts
to eliminate from the cinema the elements borrowed from literature and
the theatre. Such endeavours are particularly noticeable in the early films
of Robakowski, which are characterised by a markedly test-like quality.
In later years Robakowski focused his attention on the relationships between
the mechanical character of the equipment used in film-making and the psychophysiological
nature of the cameraman. In Robakowski's interpretation these relationships
are based on mutual influences. The mechanical-biological records led to
another stage in Robakowski's film-making, that of the personalist, "individual"
cinema, characterised by a considerable degree of subjectivity, an evident
link with the personality of the artist. The artistic transgressions, game
playing and energetic values of works, there were characteristics of the
cinema of Robakowski and, to some extend, works of the other members the
FFW as well. The participants of the FFW were particularly preoccupied
with the relationships between the reality and its audio-visual representation,
and between the reality, its reflection and the spectator. In his analysis
of reality Wojciech Bruszewski emphasised the existence of the dichotomy
between the material (external) and the spiritual (subject to individual
perception) dimensions of reality, both inherent in the concept of reality
itself. He put forward a thesis that our contact with reality is not of
direct nature, but is mediated by language instead.
Zbigniew Rybczynski started his film career in the early 1970', as
a member of the "Film Form Workshop". But he occupied there a very separate
position. Rybczynski's interests were focused on the formal arrangement
of an image, its orchestration and atonement to music. Yet, the visualisation
of musical structures was not an ultimate objective of his experiments,
providing only a framework of reference for a more comprehensive analysis.
Using a wide range of devices, such as an optical printer, colour filters,
zoom, a frame by frame camera, and combining them with live action footage,
Rybczynski arrived at a unique, idiosyncratic style of his own. One can
find in such a style the desire of creating a world independent on reality
and more perfect, the virtual world. In many films this virtual world of art
is produced through Rybczynski's inclination to create a closed composition, to introduce order into the many-level, many-motif film
structure, varied in its substance, by reducing it to the form of circle.
Circle - the perfect figure, each point of whose circumference is of the
same distance from the centre, whose each point is both the beginning and
end, circle in which the motion once started goes eternally and acquires
a static quality. In these films we can find the same structure: the end
is a return to the starting point. This type of composition makes more
distinct the autonomy of the film world, it makes more intensive the inner
closeness of the work and makes us reluctant to refer anything from its
area to the outer world. Each element of the film refers us only to its
other components and the film as a whole fulfils the Kantian postulate
of beauty in itself. Zbigniew Rybczynski's work is a very consistent phenomenon,
that the ideas used in one film in the state of their inception will flourish,
will become in later films dominant and basic features. Rybczynski returns
to past ideas not only because they have in the meantime assumed a new
shape but also in order to find out how they will behave in the new circumstances.
At the same time the techniques he applies frequently do not let him contemplate
the results of his work before it has been finished, as only then the concepts
can be confronted with their final effects. Indeed in the case of this
artist the word "experiment" sounds very true. Those spectators who do
not know Rybczynski's output and are looking now his films may be convinced
that they have to do with video realisations. The style of this artist
seems to have anticipated the possibilities offered by the video technique.
He used to do at the same time one and the other, video in film, as he
was striving to achieve his aims and in doing so was rejecting all that
stood in his way. Cinema, with all its possibilities, was only a substitute
for the tools he actually needed. A substitute for video. So he used cinema
in such a way as to achieve the results that could be produced only by
video. A dozen of years later he would say: "Film is dying away. Only video
is alive". No wonder therefore that his films did anticipate it sometimes.
In the film Take five (1972) the characters were appearing simultaneously
owing to the overlapping shots. In the New Book (1975) the simultaneousness
of the numerous motives was achieved owing to the partition of the screen
into sections and the parallel showing of them. In the Tango (1980) the
characters appeared again in the same time-space and the same picture, but being in fact separated, deprived
of any contact between one another. The distance between these films demonstrates
not only the evolution of Rybczynski's poetics going from the well-known
techniques, and arrives eventually at dazzling innovations. It also shows
the process of leaving the cinema and reaching the video. The image in
the Tango seems no longer to look like the image in film with the latter's
texture, light values, reference to the world of matter. Instead it is
getting increasingly closer to the world of video, formed by the blue box
and the techniques of the overlapping, multi-layer composition of the image.
"There is nothing more to be discovered in the cinema".
Urszula Czartoryska, Visual Researches, Theory and Praxis, in: Stefan
& Franciszka Themerson. Visual Researches, catalogue, Museum of Art,
Ryszard W. Kluszczynski, Avant-garde Film and Video Art in Poland.
An Historical Outline, in: The Middle of Europe, ed. R. W. Kluszczynski,
Centre for Contemporary Art, Warsaw 1992.
Ryszard W. Kluszczynski, Absolute Against Casuality. Zbigniew Rybczynski's
Cinema 1972-1980, "Exit. New Art in Poland", 1993, NR 3 (15), s. 608-611.
Ryszard W. Kluszczynski, Skizze zur Geschichte des Avantgardefilms
in Polen, "Journal Film. Die Zeitschrift fur das andere Kino", 1994, NR 1 (27).
Stefan Themerson, The Urge to Create Visions, Gaberbocchus - De Harmonie,
Nicholas Wadley, On Stefan Themerson, "Comparative Criticism", 12,
Janusz Zagrodzki, Outsiders of the Avant-garde, in: Stefan & Franciszka Themerson. Visual Researches...
Received on 2003-01-03